this harmonica is in rough shape, however it does make noise please look at the pictures, they are part of the description. all of my items come from local estates. please look at the pictures and email with any questions. checks are acceptable. All items are listed to the best of our ability; they are mainly in USED condition and sold AS-IS. I do not accept RETURNS through the automated process due to a rash of Buyers automatically selecting the “defective” reason code even though the real reason code is “just didn’t like” or “change my mind”. After a certain percentage of “defective” returns, increases their fees considerably to sellers as well as standing. However, if an item is not as described or truly defective, I will certainly work with a buyer about returning the item. Just please contact me through the email/messaging process to initiate within 14 days of receiving the item. You will find that I more than fair and reasonable.